Do you become a "subject" of the Emperor when you naturalize?

For those naturalizing to Japan that come from republics, the thought of linking yourself legally to a state that has a monarch, even a "mere" constitutional one, may feel strange or uncomfortable. Are you a "subject"?

The TL;DR answer for Japanese nationals: No.

A "republic", such as France or the United States, is a sovereign state that lacks a monarch. In many republics, their formation occurred after the explicit rejection of a monarch based government. However, just because a government has a king or queen or emperor or empress and is therefore not a republic does not mean that everybody is a "subject".

As a general rule of thumb, when sovereignty lies with a royal family, emperor/empress, or a king/queen, the people of the country are referred to as "subjects". When sovereignty lies with the national People, they're usually called citizens.

(The United Kingdom, another constitutional monarchy, currently has both citizens and subjects. The complicated topic as to who is a British subject and who is a British citizen and why is defined, but won't be covered here due to scope)

All Japanese nationals, both natural-born and naturalized, are citizens under the modern Constitution. This is because the very first article of the Constitution explicitly spells out that sovereignty lies with the People (capital "P", meaning national citizen), not the Emperor, and defines modern Japanese nationals as "citizens" (囜民 {kokumin}) / "the People", not "subjects" (臣民 {shimmin}):
Chapter Ⅰ: The Emperor
Article 1: The Emperor shall be the symbol of the State and of the unity of the People, deriving his position from the will of the people with whom resides sovereign power.

第章 {dai isshō} å€©çš‡ {Tennō}　
第条 {dai ichi jō} å€©çš‡ã¯、 {Tennō wa,}日本囜の象城であり {Nippon-koku no shōchō deari}日本囜民統合の象城であ぀お、 {Nihon kokumin tōgō no shōchō de atsute,}この地䜍は、 {kono chii wa,}䞻暩の存する {shuken no sonsuru}日本囜民の総意に基く。 {Nihon kokumin no sōi ni motozuku.}
This is very different from the previous constitution, known as the Constitution of the Empire of Japan (倧日本垝囜憲法 {Dai-Nippon Teikoku Kempō}) or more commonly as the Meiji Constitution (明治憲法 {Meiji Kempō}). In that constitution, Chapter 1, Article 4 declares that the sovereignty of Japan lies within the Emperor:
Chapter Ⅰ: The Emperor
Article 4: The Emperor is the head of the Empire, combining in Himself the rights of sovereignty, and exercises them, according to the provisions of the present Constitution.

第䞀章　倩皇
第四条　倩皇ハ囜ノ元銖ニシテ統治暩ヲ総攬シ歀ノ憲法ノ条芏ニ䟝リ之ヲ行フ
In the Meiji Constitution, Japanese people are explicitly referred to as "subjects" (臣民 {shimmin}) (ex. "Rights and Duties of Subjects" / 臣民暩利矩務) throughout the document, as opposed to "citizens" (囜民 {kokumin}) in the current document.

A modern Japanese regular (red & blue) passport refers to the bearer as a Japanese National (『日本囜民』 {"Nippon kokumin"}) by the "Minister for Foreign Affairs of Japan" (日本囜倖務倧臣 {Nippon-koku gaimu daijin}), and there is no mention of the Emperor anywhere in it.

Also, when you naturalize, there is no mention of the Emperor in any of the documents you sign, and the main oath you sign is to swear to obey the modern Japanese Constitution and its laws and be a good citizen. No pledge of allegiance to the Emperor or anybody else is required.

So yes, when you naturalize, you get to say that your country has a royal family with an Emperor. And he is your Emperor. But he is merely a symbol of Japan's unity according to the Constitution — which you do sign an oath (宣誓 {sensei}) to — and he gets his position from the will of Japan's citizens / People, which now includes you.

Popular posts from this blog

How much did it actually cost to naturalize?

Image
Pennies, compared to most other developed countries In 2010, an article was published here about how much it costs to apply for naturalization. It was true then, and it's still true now in 2022: The application itself is free . ¥0, nada, zilch. Compare that to the US ($725) , UK (£1,330) , Germany (€255) . However, there are many things throughout the process that can cost money: getting your civil documents both in Japan and your home country, tax documents, driving record, etc. You will also to make personal appearances to your local Legal Affairs Bureau. Here I will talk about how much it cost me personally, including the cost of gathering all documents, photocopying, travel, etc. List of Expenses Below is the list of my naturalization-related expenses. All told, it cost me about ¥18,500 to make a successful application. It is worth repeating: There is no application fee . Everything in the list above are expenses related to getting documents I need to submit with my naturaliza...
Read more →

Types of Japanese Passports

Image
The vast majority of people that naturalize will probably apply for a "red" Japanese passport after their 戞籍 { koseki } (family register) is created — which takes about a couple weeks followed by a few weeks for the passport to be issued. It is not necessary to apply for a passport. Just like the United States, the vast majority of the populace never actually travels outside of their country for their lifetime. However, realisticly speaking, it's very likely that a naturalized person would have a Japanese passport as they most likely have family ties overseas. Language The passport is in two languages: English and Japanese. Very old passports, similar to my U.S. passport, also had French, the language of diplomacy. My oh my, how the French empire's influence has faded. My last U.S. passport added Spanish. My oh my, how South, Central, and Latin America's influence has increased! ☺ On current Japanese passports, the message from the Minister of Foreig...
Read more →

All about Japanese personal inkan/hanko/chops/seals

Image
"signing" a payment slip at a bank In Japan (and other Asian countries), it is traditional practice to use an 印鑑 { inkan } ( aka 印章 { inshō } ) — colloquially called a 刀子 { hanko } in Japanese or "chop" in British English — instead of a signature for acknowledging / signing / accepting documents. Pedantically speaking, a 刀子 hanko is the actual stamping object, and an 印鑑 inkan is the ink impression that is made, but many native Japanese use the two words interchangeably. In the 21st century, Japanese recommend having three types of seals: one for casual informal acceptance: 認印 { mitomein } one for your bank accounts: 銀行印 { ginkō-in } the "real" registered one: ( 実印 { jitsuin } ) While it's perfectly possible to use just one seal for all of these functions, most people use at least two or three for the same reason that people should use different passwords for different services on the internet: in the case of a compromised s...
Read more →